Use each metric for a different question
Gross rental yield is a fast income screen. Net rental yield improves it by subtracting operating costs. Cap rate focuses on net operating income before financing, which makes it useful for comparing properties with different loan structures. Cash-on-cash return then adds financing and asks how hard the cash you invested is working.
No single metric should decide an acquisition. Vacancy, maintenance, service charges, taxes, insurance, financing and exit assumptions can materially change the result.
